My Little Pony I feel like a wedge has been driven between us. It’s not you it’s me; actually that’s a complete lie, it’s entirely you. Nothing personal, it’s just whenever I walked past your house you’d run up to the fence like an excited dog greeting the mailman and with great enthusiasm invited me to your tea party where I can make some new friends and enjoy the lovely cakes and build long-lasting friendships while singing songs about our feelings. But having social anxiety I responded to you in the usual manner I do when someone enthusiastically tries to get me out of my comfort zone while being suspiciously nice which was to smash a bottle over your head and run away. But lord knows you didn’t keep trying. For the next several years we repeated this process, you run up all bright-eyed and filled with love and I always had a bottle on hand to help with my escape. It was nice of you to not press charges, but the city finally caught me on littering your sidewalk with broken glass for seven seasons so consider this review as an apology and court appointed community service.
I think I should clarify a bit more in saying that I’m reviewing the “Friendship is Magic” series of MLP, since any earlier interpretations of the show are so bad that they’re used by the government for torturing suspected terrorists. But the Friendship is Magic series lasted for seven seasons and just started their eighth so they must be doing something right. But I’ve always kept my distance since being engrossed in nerd culture the last thing I wanted to do was to make myself even more of an outcast and get into a show that’s aimed at young or pre-teen girls. My goodness how shiny my glass house is today and the weather is perfect for me to throw on my gender bend Star Butterfly cosplay and practice my stone juggling. But to be fair I think me giving MLP an honest chance came about when Star Vs. The Forces of Evil came into my life, blew my mind and showed me that shows intended for girls can be enjoyable for all audiences if it’s executed properly with good characters, writing, art direction, etc. So will MLP surprise me like Star did? Will it climb the runs like Star and become one of the most important aspects of my life? Well I guess you’ll have to read to find out everybody, after all this isn’t my first review rodeo.
In the magical land of Equestria, the population is mostly made up of earth ponies who are fantastic farmers, unicorns who are magicians to a frankly Merlin/Dumbledor degree and pegasi who can fly and manage weather. All sporting pastel colors and “cutie marks” on their flanks to show their calling in life. Equestria being the only civilization I can think of where it’s culturally appropriate to stare at someone’s ass. Our protagonist is a unicorn named Twilight Sparkle, anti-social book-worm nerd bitch and star student at Canterlot’s magic school who discovers the legend of the elements of harmony and a prophecy about a great impending evil that will return after a thousand years, the dreaded Nightmare Moon. So Twilight begins to prepare for this great evil’s return and find a way to save the world. Or she would if she wasn’t put on party planning duty for the upcoming Summer Sun Celebration. So her mentor Queen Celestia; yes I’m well aware that her canon title is Princess, but seeing as how Equestria is a matriarchal country and no one out ranks her, that makes her a fucking queen, yes the writers said that the title of “Princess” is the highest position in all of Equestria but I’d love for them to say that to my face when Hasbro isn’t withholding food from them; decides that Twilight should go to Ponyville to get out of the house, make some friends that don’t have a glossary other than her dragon Spike and make sure the citizens are ready for the festival.
You may be wondering why I called Twilight a bitch earlier, well that’s because in the beginning of the series she’s a fucking bitch. Not even five minutes into the series she blows off a few ponies that invite her to a party, views the friendly and kindhearted ponies of Ponyville as “crazy” and when she starts to meet the other five ponies in the main cast she gets a look of disgust on her face whenever they mention the prospect of being friends mostly because it cuts into her studying and every time it looks like she’s about to say, “what the fuck is this thing you call “friends?” I don’t think I’ve ever read that book before.” So after a few more anti-social Twilight moments the Summer Sun Celebration begins only to be halted with the prophecy coming true of Nightmare Moon returning and Queen Celestia’s disappearance. Maybe she was kidnapped by Nightmare Moon but the show doesn’t tell us so maybe she was just getting out of her late night pottery class or she’s caught in a fire fight with some pie thieves or she’s playing Cuphead and stuck on that fucking queen bee cause she’s a double-decker bitch sandwich who can get fucked on a hard roll. Aren’t imaginations just the greatest?
So Twilight goes on a quest to find the elements of harmony, save Celestia and defeat Nightmare Moon with the help of the other main characters. Fluttershy, a timid and gentle Pegasus that can talk to animals who represents kindness. Pinkie Pie, a rambunctious goof ball earth pony who represents laughter. Applejack, a strong apple farming earth pony who represents honesty. Rainbow Dash, a brave and athletic Pegasus and the poster girl for gay pony pride who represents loyalty. And last but not least there’s Rarity, a posh fashionista drama queen unicorn who represents generosity and what a coincidence that these five ponies share the qualities of five out of the six elements of harmony. So they travel to the old castle of the two sisters to find the elements and along the way they come across obstacles that reveal what element of harmony they represent.
“Quick question” I ask to MLP, “why didn’t Applejack just tell Twilight that if she let go Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy would catch her?”
MLP giggled “Well so we can see that AppleJack represents the element of honesty, silly.”
“Yeah, but she’d still be telling the truth, the whole “just let go trust me” thing is just dramatic for like no reason. Also why have these big reveals to show what the five ponies represent whatever element? We already know what elements they represent when Twilight reads off the list in her history book and the ponies couldn’t be more center stage if they had the fucking lime light in their eyes for each of their corresponding elements, you basically revealed it to us twice.” And I’ve said the word “element” so many times it’s gone all weird on me.
So they go to the castle find out that Twilight is the missing sixth element of magic, defeat Nightmare Moon, Celestia shows up, Twilight discovers how powerful your magic can be when you have friends because friendship is magic (sometimes this shit writes itself) and then we meet Princess Luna, Celestia’s little sister, actual princess and former Nightmare Moon. Yeah not a bad way to start the series off, Nightmare Moon was a pretty cool antagonist despite being as threatening as a washing machine with an unbalanced load. I did have a sense of dread around the climax though “Oh Christ, this fucking friendship twee thing is gonna be beaten to death isn’t it?” I thought gripping my insulin needle. Well yes it is, but it’s not as unbearable as I once thought it being, it’s mostly around the resolution of the story of each episode when Twilight or whoever writes to Queen Celestia about the lessons they learned in the magic of friendship (hurk!) which after a while starts to try my patience and not in the sugary overload sense (though that too starts to grate at a certain point) but in the “Hey here’s this week’s lesson! Now let’s write to Queen Celestia and go over it again just in case you missed it!” We already learned the lesson today in the resolution of the plot ,why the fuck are we going over it again? Just for good measure? Because the cast likes to hear themselves talk? MLP do you really think your audience is that stupid that they have to be told the episode’s lesson twice? Then again people didn’t willingly eat detergent back then so maybe they were just hoping for the best and preparing for the worst when writing the earlier episodes.
The story in each episode is mostly slice of life based. A problem comes up, one or more of the “mane six” get involved, solve the problem, learn a lesson, have tea and cake. To the show’s credit this isn’t the case in every episode. Some episodes follow this formula, others have other characters in the spotlight like the Cutie Mark Crusaders and then there are the villain plots which are handled about as well as a bar of soap in the bath but more on that later. Also to the show’s credit it was nice to see it evolve from writing to Queen Celestia about lessons learned, to keeping a journal of their adventures to just having the lesson play out organically by the resolution of the plot, makes the whole lesson seem a lot less fucking tedious and more enjoyable because we’re not hearing the same thing over and over again like a skipping record. I know I’m making it sound like the episodes are a chore to get through, but honestly only a small selection of episodes are a chore (whenever Spike has a song being one of the worst fucking chores on earth) the rest are rather fun and have jokes in it that are actually funny and play off the characters in the scene really well and excuse me while I find my socks because the realization of me having fun and actual comedy that legitimately makes me laugh in any version of MLP just blew them to the stratosphere. Part of the fun comes from characters that aren’t super annoying and the other part is timing. This series actually has great timing with the line delivery of the characters that just add a bit more weight to the punchline.
Now since I brought up the characters I might as well talk about them. None of the characters are particularly deep but then again they don’t need to be, they’re all interesting enough for us to want to be invested in their lives and passions and just enjoy what’s going on in the episode. Twilight Sparkle is well read in magic, super neat and organized, does her best to be a good student to Celestia and always makes time to help her friends and any other pony in trouble and eventually becomes the princess of friendship (I’ll grant her the princess title since Twilight doesn’t so much have a castle and a kingdom, as much as a glorified club house in Ponyville. Mayor Mare still calls the shots in town which I personally find hilarious). Applejack is a hard-working farmer with a large and tightly knit family who always does what she thinks is right. Pinkie Pie is a kooky and energetic party girl who gets the most out of life when she makes others smile. Rainbow Dash is athletic and arrogant but will always have your back in times of need who dreams of flying with the Wonderbolts (Equestrian air force). Fluttershy is a sweet little cinnamon roll filled with kindness for others who takes care of any animal in need. And lastly there’s Rarity, fashionista and entrepreneur a.k.a my favorite character a.k.a best character. Even before I started watching the show certain people have compared me to her. But I get it now, we’re both artists with high standards, we both dress for success, we’re both one part greedy and one part generous (she can be greedy despite her element thing but that’s fine, it just makes her more believable as a character), we both have a thing about cleanliness, and we both have a flair for the dramatic. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve wanted to fall on a fancy couch completely distraught every time my toast landed butter side down.
in fact, a lot of the side characters in the show have little quirks and traits that make them fun and interesting. My favorite of which are the Cutie Mark Crusaders who might as well be main characters seeing how many episodes focus on them. The CMC is made up of three fillies, Apple Bloom, who’s Applejack’s little sister, Sweetie Belle, Rarity’s little sister and Scootaloo who’s Rainbow Dash’s honorary little sister. Their episodes mostly deal with them trying to figure out what their calling in life is so they can finally attain their cutie marks. They’re actually some of the best episodes because all their episodes are their own contained story, the mane six have their adventures solving friendship problems and whatnot while the CMC deal with self discovery, helping ponies with their own cutie mark problems, and dealing with being bullied for having “blank flanks” which is basically calling them talentless losers. but they keep their heads held high and keep trying different things and helping others which leads up to one of the best episodes in the series “Crusaders of the Lost Mark,” where the CMC learn that their long time bully Diamond Tiara is the way she is because of the way she’s treated by her mother, distant, cold and the attitude of “your either a winner or a loser and no daughter of mine is a loser.” So they actually help Diamond Tiara learn that her cutie mark means that she’s a good leader, not a bully and when the CMC realize how great it feels to help others with their cutie mark problems they ironically get their cutie marks in the one field that’s been right under their noses since they began the CMC. You might have noticed a lack of sarcasm and swears but that’s because I can’t really think of anything negative about the CMC, they’re genuinely sweet episodes that show that it’s ok to try different things and that you’ll find your calling in life when you can and that there’s no need to worry about it.
So aside from the CMC the background is filled with fun quirky characters who are interesting. Except for Queen Celestia of course, who might be one of the most boring characters in the entire series. “What? How can you say Princess Celestia is boring?” MLP cries out, “She’s not boring, she’s just mysterious.” To which I respond; No she’s not mysterious, Queen Celestia is boring. Eclipsa Butterfly is mysterious. The Diamond Authority is mysterious. Bill Cypher is mysterious. Marceline the Vampire Queen is mysterious. Princess fucking Luna is more mysterious and interesting than her sister is with revealing something as simple as us learning what her job is; governing the dream realm, working in the darkness with only herself as company, helping ponies have sweet dreams and in one reveal it turns out that Luna’s role as dream keeper is completely and utterly invaluable to the mental health of all of Equestria in that if she wasn’t there to dispose of nightmares, most of the inhabitants of Equestria could have serious damage done to their psyche. But Celestia is just the perfect ruler, with perfect leadership skills and is so perfect in so many ways she seems just as lifeless as the shitty toys Hasbro makes of her. See what makes a character mysterious is something like the nature of their work (like Luna) or a character that raises more questions about them when one question is answered. We’re given a little knowledge of who they are and subtle clues or hints sets your imagination off like fireworks at a rave. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t hate Celestia. In fact she’s a focus in one of the best episodes in the entire series, “Royal Problems,” where she and Luna switch roles for a day to see how the other sister lives. This episode is great because we see the royal sisters acting like real sisters, but most importantly we see Celestia acting like a character with faults. She’s sarcastic, passive aggressive, condescending, thinks Luna’s job is child’s play, and even starts talking to herself when she learns how lonely Luna’s job really is, even going so far as to beg for Luna’s help when she realizes how difficult battling nightmares is. It’s a fantastic episode and really gives Celestia much-needed depth; granted it took them seven fucking seasons to do so, but better late than never I suppose. What I’d love to see is an episode where Celestia miraculously has nothing to do. No royal business or problems to solve every one is doing well and she actually has a day off but she discovers that she doesn’t know what to do with herself when she’s not working. Maybe she can try hanging out with the other royals but they’ll be too busy or maybe she’ll try to discover a hobby, play video games with Luna, hang out with the Cutie Mark Crusaders, ask Twilight for advice. You know something that shows that even horse Gods get bored when they realize they got nothing going on. Or better yet, have an episode or two that focuses on Celestia after she banished Luna to the moon. Showing that Celestia was filled with guilt for what she was forced to do and shame for letting Luna fall so far into darkness for the thousand years she was banished. Maybe showing that Celestia was always filled with regret and sadness at every Summer Sun Festival and was left alone to grieve before she actually raises the sun. Come the fuck on, she banished her sister! That’s not an easy thing to do even if it was an “it was either her or me” scenario, can’t we see her morn? You know some depth?
So about those villains, while we’re still on the subject of characters. Like the protagonists, the villains aren’t particularly deep but at least they have their reasons for doing what they did. Nightmare Moon wanted to cast the world in eternal night and banish Celestia, Discord wanted to turn the world into his own chaotic playground, Queen Chrysalis wanted to feed off the love ponies had for Queen Cadence (yeah I said she’s a queen too, she has her own empire. what? You think she’d still be a princess? It doesn’t fucking work that way!) and then come back to kidnap all of the royals and the mane six and replace them with changelings, Tirac wanted revenge against Celestia and Luna for sending him to Tartarus and used Discord to further his plan of being a magic god, the Pony of Shadows wanted revenge against Star Swirl and his mates aka the “original” mane six for treating him like used dishwater, Starlight Glimmer wanted every pony to be equal and then became a revenge driven stalker when Twilight ruins her cult racket and King Sombra wanted to…uh; come to think of it, what the fuck did King Sombra want to do exactly? Take over the Crystal Empire again? I guess? I don’t know cause the show doesn’t tell us and not a single one of his lines tells us what his motives were. Just Celestia saying “Hey we banished this dude name Sombra a thousand years ago and his empire just reappeared, make sure that guy doesn’t show up cause he’s evil and stuff. Cadence will help you out she already set up shop in her new castle.” For all we know he might have wanted to come back to open up a bakery or a used record store. Sure the crystal ponies have some major PTSD when Sombra comes up and Sombra does address them as his “crystal slaves,” but what if that’s just how ponies addressed each other back then and he hasn’t caught up with the times, which is why I don’t talk about minorities in front of the elderly. incidentally I can only imagine and laugh at what Cadence told the crystal empire ponies when they came out of their thousand-year cryo sleep, “Hey crystal ponies! Welcome back to the real world, boy have you missed a lot and I’ll be sure to bring you up to speed but first a quick question; You guys don’t have a ruler do you? No? Sweet, I’ll just move into this wicked cool castle and set up shop. Maybe a barrier to keep Sombra out. Oh and if you all could call me your ruler that would be grand.”
So Sombra aside, the rest of the villains are pretty cool both motive and design wise. I could understand why’d they’d be pissed, Luna banished to the moon by Celestia a thousand years ago, Celestia and Luna turning Discord into a stone statue a thousand years ago, Celestia and Luna throwing Tirac in jail a thousand years ago. Hang on; Celestia banished/imprisoned Luna, Discord, Sombra and Tirac a thousand years ago? She must have very good time management skills. Maybe she was working through her lunch breaks or something. So out of all of them I think the strongest and most interesting character wise are Discord, Queen Chrysalis and Starlight Glimmer. Discord is one of the most enjoyable villains I’ve seen in cartoons mainly because world conquest is really more of a side venture, he’d much rather fuck with the cast and really get under their skin. His chaos magic is broken to shit but he chooses instead to just ruin some pony’s day, laugh at their expense and make a nice little playground for him to wreak havoc in. I also find it rather endearing that when Discord reforms the only pony he doesn’t mess with is Fluttershy, even going so far as to declare a personal vendetta against the changelings when he learns she was kidnapped and threw a bit of a hissy fit when she didn’t invite him to a huge party. Plus I love his design of a bunch of animals jammed together into a serpent like creature, it fits his chaos god motif really well.
Next is Queen Chrysalis, the head of the changeling horde. A race of insect looking ponies whom can take the form of any creature and feed off of love. Her appearance is one of the best designs in the series in my opinion, she’s basically an alacorn but black with sharp edges and insect wings. The first time Chrysalis took Cadence’s form and leached off the love of her husband to be Shining Armor to make her strong enough to beat Celestia in a duel (Only villain to beat Celestia while she was at full power by the way) and unleash changelings in Canterlot. She was defeated by the real Cadence reuniting with Shining Armor and was blasted Team Rocket style with the overwhelming power of their love for each other. Which was dumb and kind of paradoxical at the same time. Don’t changelings feed off of love? I’d think a love blast like that would be like a buffet to Chrysalis or trying to put out a grease fire with kerosene, but what the fuck do I know? Chrysalis’ second attempt at conquest was basically the same as her first attempt to replace Cadence, but on a grander scale. This time she kidnapped the royal sisters, Cadence and her family, Spike and the mane six. Basically the only forces that could screw over her plans and at the same time feed off of the love their subjects would shower the real ones with. This is honestly one of my favorite episodes in the series because the hero’s of this arc are Starlight Glimmer (now reformed), her best friend Trixi; a stage magician unicorn, Thorax; a changeling Spike befriended and Discord who was totally fine with changelings taking over until he heard Fluttershy was taken and was like “fuck this! Pack up your crap, let’s go!” At first I was like “I mean it’s cool that we see Discord, but chaos magic is more broken than Equestria magic so this’ll be over soon.” Then we find out that the changeling hive has an artifact that cancels out all non-changeling magic. It may sound like one of those situations where the phrase “well that’s fucking convenient”pops up, but it actually makes sense here. It’s a home defense system for the hive, it’s not portable and it makes the rescue mission way more exciting because we get to see three well-known magic users become totally powerless and are forced to think of ways to outsmart the changelings in the hive instead of blasting their way in. I should also mention that when Chrysalis makes her appearance in the hive it’s one of the scariest fucking things I’ve seen in the show. She appears from behind the cocooned prisoners in like a backwards crab walk and exorcists her head 180 degrees. Now that’s how you make a fucking awesome reveal MLP keep up the good work. Eventually when she’s defeated and her changelings rebel against her, Starlight gives her a chance to turn over a new leaf and become a better leader to the changelings. I was like “Oh please don’t Chrysalis! You’re the only villain we have left!” which is why I was overjoyed when Chrysalis smacked Starlight away and basically said “Fuck you I’m a queen! I’ll just make more changelings and come back to kill you all later!” I for one salute you bug horse, looking forward to when you show up again and how MLP completely fucking ruins your resolution.
Which leads me to Starlight Glimmer, who is one of my favorite characters, my favorite villain and my biggest disappointment. How can she be all three you ask? Well how can “wank” be fun to say, fun to do, but neither are socially appropriate at an office Christmas party? Allow me to explain. At the start of season five Twilight and co. find a magic map in Twilight’s castle that tells them to go to a remote part of Equestria for some reason. They come across a town of identical houses in perfect rows in the middle of a dessert. The ponies there all have identical cutie marks of an “equal” sign with dulled colored bodies, all sporting two to three different hair styles with big smiles shown through wide eyes and clenched teeth that would make a Stepford wife blush. Their leader and town founder is Starlight Glimmer, a unicorn with an overly cheery demeanor that preaches the glories of equality and how damaging special talents and cutie marks are. It got all the more weirder and creepy when they sing and the townsfolk start marching in perfect synch (even the fucking Pegasi flap their wings in synch), in perfect lines with forced smiles singing about how great their town is, how differences are bad and how great being equal is with lyrics like “…You can’t have a nightmare, if you never dream” that actually made me reel back a second in shock, because I haven’t seen a cult in children’s media since the Happy Happiests in Earthbound (Yeah Earthbound got a T rating now but that’s not how it was originally) and it was set up in a similar way too, we’re all used to this cheery and bright world only for us to wind up in what appears to be a completely foreign land with such a shift in tone it’s rather jarring. So here’s a character who’s established a pony pseudo communist cult whose residence seem more like wind-up toys than actually living creatures (There’s a bit of irony there somewhere) who are all totally fine with being a rubber stamp of each other and the damnedest thing is, I can actually kind of sympathize with what Starlight’s trying to do here. Since the beginning of the series we see cutie marks being a topic of bullying, superiority and being trapped in a box, doing this one thing and not really doing anything else because it’s not what your cutie mark is telling you to do. Then here’s a character who says “Wouldn’t it be great if we could all live equally? No bullying, no differences, just ponies living in harmony with no pony being better than the other?” Need I remind the readers of the Cutie Mark Crusaders’ struggles to become accepted by finding their cutie marks? Something like Starlight’s town would sound very, very appealing to ponies like the CMC.
So Twilight and co. get their cutie marks stolen by Starlight and get thrown into a rehabilitation room to brain wash them to be like the towns people (it’s really creepy since we see them slowly lose their individuality), eventually they escape and expose Starlight’s real cutie mark thus causing her town to rebel against her. Though I was kind of hoping Starlight would try to save her skin by saying “Look cutie marks are bad, but since my magic is the only kind that can make every pony equal I’ll keep mine till every other cutie mark has been replaced then get rid of mine.” She runs off and swears revenge against Twilight for fucking up her whole cult town like Snidely Whiplash, then spends the rest of the season stalking Twilight plotting her next move. I’m serious about the stalking thing, you find Starlight in the background in certain episodes gathering information. A friend of mine told me this and I thought she was just messing with me, “No really, Starlight is in the background of the cafe”” she said. I watched that episode a few times, mainly because I like it and I never noticed Starlight before. And here we venture into one of the greatest strings to Starlight’s villain character bow which is the fact that she’s not some chaos god, magic absorbing centaur, shape shifter queen, or horse god, she’s just a regular unicorn. Sure she’s a magic prodigy who can rival or even surpass Twilight, but for all we know Starlight could very well have been Twilight’s neighbor and the fact that she can just blend into the background with the rest of the pony populace is actually rather intriguing and scary as far as villains in this show are concerned. She learned two very important plot points, one was that the legendary wizard Star Swirl the Bearded had a spell that allowed him to travel one week back in time and two was the fact that each member of the mane six got their cutie marks at the same time from the same event of Rainbow Dash performing a sonic rainboom.
With that in mind Starlight steals Star Swirl’s spell, infiltrates Twilight’s castle and uses the magic map to go back several years to where it all began with Rainbow Dash’s race. Starlight fucks up the race to prevent any of the mane six from getting their cutie marks which causes major problems in the future. Twilight gets sucked through the time warp again and again each time Starlight messes with the past which shows different futures where the villains win. King Sombra declaring war on Equstria (guess he didn’t want to open up a bakery after all), the changelings re-creating Invasion of the Body Snatchers, Nightmare Moon returning and banishing Celstia, my personal favorite is the future where Discord wins and he makes Celestia and Luna his court jesters because of course he fucking would. So since the mane six don’t get together, Equestria is doomed to destruction which sounds pretty ridiculous, but it makes sense in regards to the story. The mane six has been the ones to save the day since season one so with them gone who’s left to save the day? Apparently not Celestia, so much for being an immortal horse god, but I digress. I just want to point out that I think this is one of the best villain battles in the series and it’s not a battle like the Tirac vs. Twilight fight, this is more like a game of wits and cleverness. No matter what Twilight tries to do to stop Starlight from fucking up the past, Starlight knows that as long as she’s in the past the future will change. it doesn’t matter if Twilight appears a few seconds before Starlight in the past or tries to fight her, just them being there ruins the time line so Starlight barely has to put in any effort in fighting Twilight because the results will be the same, she’s always one step ahead of her and I fucking love it. Twilight then decides to drag Starlight back to the future to show her how her actions essentially destroy the world and then Starlight reveals her reason why she went evil. “Oh boy!” I said excitedly, “We’re about to find out the motivation behind the best villain in the series! Wait, let me guess. Starlight had a friend who she was very close too when they were little, who got their cutie mark before she did and was showered with praise. Soon the rest of the kids in her town were getting cutie marks but Starlight was the only one without one, which caused her to be bullied and feel like a complete outcast, maybe her friend thought that he/she was better than her and told Starlight to get lost. Then years later after a bitter and jaded Starlight gets her cutie mark for her talent in magic she sees a filly without a cutie mark getting bullied. She sees a lot of herself in this filly and decides to finally do something about it and this is what drives her to create the spell which makes ponies equal and founded her Jones Town to make her dream come true. Tell me I’m right MLP. MLP? Why do you look like you’re gonna start crying?”
So it turns out she did have a childhood friend, who did get his cutie mark before her and the reason why she went evil was because! His parents sent him off to magic school and she never saw him again which caused her to totally abandon the concept of friendship… I threw my head back in a laugh, “Hahaha! No seriously, what was the reason MLP? What? That’s really it? Something she and her friend had no control over was the reason why she went evil? What the fuck?! Are you seriously telling me that the best villain in the series went evil over something so fucking petty?! Dude, just write him a fucking letter every so often! It’s not like Equestria doesn’t have a mail service, they literally have a pony express to get letters and parcels from here to there.” But nope, evil because the concept of pen pals never crossed her mind. So Twilight realizing she can’t beat her in a magic fight convinces Starlight to give friendship another chance and to stop fucking with the timeline then Twilight convenes with her friends to discuss what they’re going to do with Starlight; for you know, destroying Equestria over and over again. “Ok.” I said with concern, “I’m going to guess that instead of banishing her or throwing her in Tartarus or whatever, Twilight will be like, “Starlight Glimmer. You have committed a heinous crime of altering the timelines and putting Equestria at great risk. After much thought I will now administer your punishment. As the Princess of Friendship I hereby sentence you to… community service. You will live here at the castle and become my pupil to learn the importance of friendship and to use these skills to help other ponies. Lert’s start with our first lesson, making a friend. Hi, my name is Twilight Sparkle, what’s yours?” You know a punishment that’ll help her make a difference in the world and help her on the path of friendship? MLP it looks like you’re gonna start crying again…” So Starlight does become Twilight’s pupil, but the rest of the fucked up puppet master, time traveling things she did is completely and totally forgiven instantly, not once is the word “punishment” or any words like it in the resolution of the plot, which is fucking insane.
Look I love Starlight, not as much as I love Rarity but she’s pretty far up there and I’m actually pissed that everyone is so forgiving of a character that not only manipulated free will, but destroyed the world while she was at it. I’m not expecting an execution or anything but some kind of punishment is preferred over everyone having tea and cake at the end. Even the village Starlight controlled seemed totally cool with forgiving her. Fuck you’d think they of all ponies would hold a grudge of being controlled. Nope every pony is just cool with accepting Starlight and they’re all friends now. No MLP I’m not mad, I’m just disappointed in you. Very, very dissappointed. Here I foolishly thought that you finally grasped the concept of a great antagonist with depth, but you made Starlight a petty moustache twirling villain just a few steps above Dick Dastardly. I’ve heard that Starlight is/was hated amongst the MLP community and I think this was the reason why, a major villain doing terrible things only to be totally forgiven is frustrating and stupid. But I think the one thing people need to understand is that Starlight isn’t a bad character, she was just handled terribly. Again I love Starlight and it’s mostly because of her personality, she’s got a bit of social anxiety because interacting with others and trying to make new friends makes her nervous and stressed but still does what she can to follow Twilight’s example in friendship and even becomes a voice of reason when Twilight is in distress, but often falls back on bad habits and sometimes uses magic as an easy way to finish friendship lessons. Another reason I like her is the way she uses magic, while Twilight is very “by the book” when it comes to magic, Starlight usually combines spells to make something new and more powerful, like combining spells to mind control Twilights friends.
I know what you’re thinking, “Slade you hypocritical sack of gorilla spunk, how can you like a character like Starlight so much when you said you kind of hated Mabel Pines for manipulating free will?” And to be honest I was really baffled by this realization as well, but I think I can explain why. See when Starlight first fucks with free will it’s to establish her as the season’s villain and to show a taste of how powerful her magic is, the second time in “Every little thing she does” it’s used as a point of humor. Starlight doesn’t want to disappoint Twilight so she tries to use magic to cram five friendship lessons into a single afternoon and in a panic and having no idea what she was getting herself into mixes spells to make five of the mane six follow every one of Starlight’s commands to a literal degree. But the key reason why I still love Starlight despite the free will manipulation, is that Starlight actually feels bad for what she did. She feels shame for doing that to her friends and when she apologizes you can really get a sense that she means it. Mabel however has no remorse for what she did. She didn’t care about the consequences, all she cared about was being the best matchmaker and when it all blew up in her face she didn’t even apologize, the writers basically gave her a free pass to do something terrible with no fallout.
The animation? Yeah it’s pretty good. It’s colorful and lively and I can forgive the animation fuck ups like established earth ponies sprouting wings and extra or dislocating body parts because I’m sure the animation process can’t be easy with the Hasbro slave masters cracking whips every other second. At first it was kind of creepy how all the characters looked like living plastic, but that wears off after a while and you just accept that this is how the MLP universe rolls with its characters, except for babies who look like pop vinyls come to life and will never not be creepy. But character designs are pretty solid over all, MLP understands animation basics and have big lovely eyes to portray emotions which I personally adore (I have a thing for eyes). I have to hand it to Lauren Faust for making sure that the ponies in this series are actually appealing to the eyes and staying clear of the uncanny valley. Fun fact, realistic looking ponies in pastel colors is fucking creepy. everything looks nice from manes to colors to cutie marks (despite most of the populace having an hourglass, cherries, scrolls and a desert island as a cutie mark) and the occasional references in the background which are sprinkled in for fun. Like ponies who look like the The Dude, Walter and Donny from “The Big Labowski” (the Dude’s cutie mark is a rug and when I saw that I thought I was gonna laugh up my lungs and I laughed harder when I found out he fucking sells rugs!), the 10th Doctor and Rose, “Pretty Woman” ponies, the twins from “The Shining,” There’s even a reference to fucking Bioshock infinite which blew my mind, basically what I’m saying is it’s fun to play “I spy” while watching the show.
To be honest I thought the singing was gonna be the lynch pin for me not liking this series but the songs in it are like 95% good and listenable, songs like “In Our Town,” “The Art of the Dress,” “Luna’s Future” are all really good and then there’s “You’re in My Head Like a Catchy Song”a.k.a the best song in the series from the best episode in the entire series a.k.a “The Perfect Pear.” The episode dealt with the Apple siblings (Applejack, Apple Bloom and Big Macintosh) learning about their parent’s history and the song was perfectly crafted to show the love between them grow and flourish into a believable relationship where you can actually see and feel the care they have for each other.
So after talking about the lovely things in the show I like and the annoying things in the show that annoy me I feel it’s time to dish out a few gut punches to the show. Normally I enjoy a show with subtlety in its writing, Star, Gravity Falls, Over The Garden Wall, Last Airbender, all have subtlety and intrigue sprinkled with out that keep me thinking. MLP unfortunately is not very subtle, it’s about as subtle as a clown with its cock out. Oh look there’s a zebra! What are the chances of her being some kind of African voodoo shaman? Pretty fucking high apparently! Oh look buffalos, and they have feather headdresses because of course they’re supposed to be Native Americans and Yaks couldn’t be more Russian if their arch nemesis’ were a fucking flying squirrel and a moose.
I feel like I have to give a special shout out to Tirac, a villain who had everything going for him until Hasbro had to sell another shitty toy to the dumb masses. See when a toy is a byproduct of a series/movie its charming and makes sense, but Hasbro is a toy company first and a content creator second which would be fine if it weren’t for the fact that they’re too fucking cheap to get new molds made for the FIM series so all their toys look like hot vomit streaming through the uncanny valley. But I digress; Tirac was a pretty cool villain who had all of Equestria in the palm of his hands but he went out in a more humiliating way then Starlight because the only reason he was defeated was because Hasbro wanted to sell the super sayian ponies that the writers came up with when Hasbro was holding their loved ones at gun point and since no one else is saying it I will, super sayian ponies are dumb. They are literally the dumbest fucking thing about the show and I hate it more than life itself, it’s even worse than Sombra because the only reason that arc existed was to go “Hey kids! you saw your favorite mane six member turn into crystal ponies for like three seconds, now buy our toys! Buy harder!”
Then there’s the rather insulting things they do with the characters, which basically boils down into two categories. One, the writers don’t seem know who the fuck Pinkie Pie is and two, certain episodes give characters a severe case of the stupids. Here’s the thing, I like Pinkie Pie, she’s funny and a rather charming character, but the writers can’t write her consistently. See I think Pinkie’s at her best when the stoplight isn’t shown directly on her and she’s more of a deuteragonist or the comic relief, but very rarely does a Pinkie centric episode capture what makes Pinkie good and fun In most cases she’s a walking contradiction or just straight mean. One minute she’ll be singing about how her purpose in life is to make others smile and laugh the next she’s harassing a donkey who wants to be left alone and giving Fluttershy such a bad panic attack that she starts crying. Pinkie I know for a fact that you can see how horrible you’re making Fluttershy feel, you’re looking right into her eyes! It can’t be that hard to keep a character consistent since Rarity is more or less the same since episode one but I guess they lost the notebook that says “Pinkie Pie does not harass of make others cry.”
Now who has a bad case of the stupids? I can think of one grating episode “Applejack’s Day Off,” where we see Applejack go through tons of metaphorical rings of fire to get chores done on the farm only for Twilight to go “Hey, there has to be an easier way of doing this.” and Aj basically says “Holy shit, why didn’t I think of that?” I thought AJ would be one of the few lucky ones to avoid a case of the stupids but sadly I was wrong. While we’re on the subject, I hate it when the writers make AJ really mean and insensitive because she’s too honest. Look I get that that’s her thing, but she should know when to keep her mouth shut so she doesn’t intentionally hurt other pony’s feelings, like in “Honest Apple” where AJ almost ruins Rarity’s fashion show because of how blunt she was. Spike unfortunately comes down with a bad case of the stupids more often than any other character, which is a shame because I really like Spike. He reminds me of the dweeby kid who wants to get with the popular pretty girl (being Rarity) and I for one support this ship. You get your pretty girl Spike and never let go. But the two moments that come to mind are “Spike At Your Service” and “Triple Threat.” Spike at Your Service has Aj saving Spike’s life and he basically becomes her servant. The thing is AJ saved him from timber wolves and the “timber” part is quite literal. Spike’s a fire-breathing dragon! There’s no reason why he couldn’t set them ablaze and be totally ok, maybe he didn’t want to burn down the forest, but his life was in jeopardy I’m sure the fire dept would forgive him but what would I know? Triple Threat is where Spike accidentally double books a meeting with Thorax the new leader of the changelings and dragon lord Ember and does everything he can to keep them apart and spreads himself thin trying to please both of them instead of you know just saying “Hey sorry I double booked you guys, but I think I can make this work. Thorax this is Ember, Ember this is Thorax now why don’t we get started on this meeting?” See! Not so hard MLP!
But I think the most serious sin of all are episodes where Spike sings, more specifically when he has solos. The writer really, really, really need to understand that Spike. Can’t. Sing. At all. All of his songs are so excruciating that it makes me want to slice my ears off with a paper guillotine. Have we learned nothing from “Total Drama World Tour?” The show where characters who can’t sing, sang every. Single. Fucking. Episode! Have we not learned that people will hate it when characters sing as if they’re just reading it off of a cue card? Clearly not, which is why I say as soon as Spike opens his mouth to sing just go right to the next episode, don’t look back and never regret it, cause you will regret watching it.
So in summary, do I like the show? Yes. Yes, ok? I like the show, I like it a lot. Like I really, really like it. I don’t care if it hurts my man’s man cool guy facade, because I like it and if you like something you should have the courage to defend it. It’s not like I said I like Equestria Girls, that’s actually embarrassing. MLP is colorful, it’s lively, it’s charming, it’s funny and most importantly I have fun watching it, which is something that’s becoming more and more important as time goes on and I become more bitter and jaded. I’ll say that people should give it an honest chance because it is really good, ignore the stigma of past generations because Friendship is Magic is good, apart from the annoying and the bad because the good and the fun outshine it.